Compare Newmarket car insurance quotes and get the best affordable rates for free.

On average, Newmarket drivers save hundreds of dollars per year by comparing quotes with us.

Get quotes from 75+ Canadian providers in 3 minutes.

25,994 Canadians

have compared rates and saved money over the last 24 hours

What our users say:

Based on 336 reviews
August 31
very quick and reliable rates
very quick and reliable rates
Tracie N
August 15
Don’t hesitate to move your policy
My rates went up again with my current insurance even though I have barely drive...
August 12
I can’t believe how quickly I am…
I can’t believe how quickly I am getting email responses. Very happy with this...
July 25
Awesome 👍😎
Awesome 👍😎
Joshua Leong
July 15
Auto Insurance
I was looking for an insurance rate that would help me save money, I did a Googl...
Louise Beaton
July 7
Great and honest service !!!
Meaghan Ford was amazing with her service and very patient in explaining all the...
Zee Sajid
July 1
excellent service
excellent service
An Luu
June 22
Highly recommended
Excellent customer service. Was very patient and answer my customers toughly. Fo...
Karan Parmar
June 18
Chelsea was very helpful
Chelsea was very helpful, answered all my questions and set me up hassle free. S...
June 14
its the easiest thing in the world to…
its the easiest thing in the world to find insuance that isn't going to burn the...
ann watson
June 11
Very nice broker
Very nice broker. Good service. Found a great deal.
Meredith Berggren
June 9
Simple, fast, affordable!
Took a little longer than expected for the billing to go through, but otherwise...
Jonathan C
June 5
Awesome work
wow what an awesome rep. He did up everything, extremely fast and was very under...
Delroy Paul
June 4
It was a pleasure dealing with your…
It was a pleasure dealing with your broker, it made switching insurance companie...
Michael Sheridan
May 27
Excellent customer service
This is the first time I got insurances from Direct Rate.I have nothing but good...
Tejas Patel
May 26
Quick service
Quick service, good price
May 22
Imad Harrouk was great !
Imad Harrouk was great ! intelligent well spoken professional polite a perso...
james bannon
May 20
Excellent !!! Very competitive rates !!
Excellent customer services also they have very competitive rates !!
Eliza Gallant
May 18
I was treated fairly and walked through…
I was treated fairly and walked through my purchase.I enjoyed the agent was exce...
paul neville
May 14
Highly recommend
Great experience, simple to use and they gave me a lot of options at prices that...
Chandra Wilson
May 11
Easy, clear and fast. Very effective.
Rene Izquierdo de la Cruz
May 6
Sonia was very helpful and nice…
Sonia was very helpful and nice throughout the whole process. She got me the bes...
Ali Al-Rubayee

How comparing auto insurance quotes works. Hint: it’s free!


Next, we’ll show you quotes from 75+ Canadian providers. It’s free, with no commitment.


When you find the best quote, secure your Newmarket auto insurance rate by talking to a licensed broker or agent.

We can help you find cheap car insurance in Newmarket.

North of Toronto, in the heart of York Region, lies the tranquil town of Newmarket.

But even though getting around town is easy, Newmarket drivers still need the right auto insurance for their vehicles. As a city on the outskirts of the GTA, many residents find them commuting for work. With so many regular drivers, it’s no wonder that car insurance is such a big part of life in Newmarket. Luckily, has you covered.

You can get quotes from the top insurance providers quickly and easily just by using

Front view of a car. Illustration.

See how our customers save big on auto insurance.

CustomerLocationVehicleLowest RateAverage RateSaved
Quote from September 28, 2021
Male, 51 years old
Lowest Rate
Average Rate
Quote from September 27, 2021
Male, 21 years old
Lowest Rate
Average Rate

Focus on

Driving in Newmarket.

Most popular cars in Newmarket.

Based on tens of thousands of car insurance quotes at, here's a snapshot of the kind of cars Newmarket auto insurance shoppers are driving:

Popular Brands

  1. Honda
  2. Toyota
  3. Hyundai
  4. Ford
  5. Nissan

Who shops for auto insurance in Newmarket?

Our data reveals that three-quarters of auto insurance shoppers from Newmarket are male and that the average shoppers is in their late 20s:

Gender of our users


Average Age


years old

Tickets & Accidents

Have Tickets
Have Had Accidents

What can I do to get cheap car insurance in Newmarket?

It's easy — if you know how. Here are some of the best ways to lower your auto insurance premiums:

Shop around

We'll show you the most competitive rates from all the top insurers. Now you can compare quotes all in one place.

Buy the right coverage

Avoiding extra frills in your policy and paying for only the coverage you need will lower your premiums.

Drive responsibly

Your driving record impacts your rate. Fewer infractions and fines equals cheaper insurance.

Pay on time

Prompt payments can save you money on late fees and lower your premiums. Insurers love a good customer.

Bundle up

Adding a house, motorcycle, RV, or other type of insurance policy to your car insurance plan can lower your rates.

Be safe, not sorry

Safety features like winter tires and alarm systems can help reduce your insurance premium.

Stick with one insurer

Most auto insurance companies give special discounts to customers who stay with them for a number of years.

Take a course

A defensive driving course makes you a better driver and can significantly reduce your car insurance premiums.

Keep driving

The math is clear: more experience on the road equals lower car insurance premiums. Young drivers almost universally pay higher rates for car insurance. While it’s difficult for new drivers to secure cheap car insurance rates, you may be able to lower your rates by maintaining good grades and attending driving school.

Look at location

Where you drive affects your premiums. Some areas are associated with higher rates of car accidents and theft.

Choose the right car

Cars with high crash-test scores, low theft ratings, and less powerful engines tend to have cheaper insurance rates.

Track your driving

With a usage-based car insurance policy, you can turn your low-risk driving habits into lower premiums.

Your questions about driving in Newmarket, answered.

How much is car insurance in Newmarket?

If you just recently moved to Newmarket or are planning to in the near future, you might be wondering: what does car insurance in Newmarket actually cost?

It’s tricky to determine the average price of car insurance in Newmarket, because car insurance is such a customized product. Car insurance calculators geared for Newmarket drivers may require less information, but this actually makes them less accurate. A better option is to spend a little bit more time filling out a quote.

Furthermore, the average car insurance rate in Newmarket most likely isn’t what you’ll pay. Ask your insurance broker about potential discounts, maintain a safe driving record to keep your premiums low, and compare auto insurance rates across different car insurance companies in Newmarket to secure the best price.

Car insurance for new drivers in Newmarket

Are you new to the city and to driving? No problem. We’ve got helpful tips for new drivers looking for cheap car insurance in Newmarket.

If you’re a new driver looking for affordable car insurance in Newmarket, your first step should be to compare rates among the different auto insurance companies in Newmarket.

This will help you secure the best rate based on your needs, and give you an estimate for car insurance in Newmarket. You’ll have to confirm your details with a broker before your rate is guaranteed.

Car insurance in Newmarket for students

If you’re a student looking for car insurance in Newmarket, there’s a good chance you’re going to face higher rates. That’s because you haven’t acquired enough of a driving history to signal to insurers that you’re a trustworthy driver.

That said, there are still ways to get cheap auto insurance in Newmarket.

  • Start by obtaining a quote for auto insurance in Newmarket. You can do this by using a rate comparison website.
  • Avoid getting your own car, if you can. Instead, opt to get listed as the secondary driver of your parents’ car. Insurance for secondary drivers costs less than it does for the primary driver.
  • Keep up good grades in school. Some insurance companies offer discounts to students who maintain a certain GPA.
  • Take driver’s ed. Being able to show an insurance company a certificate of completion can help you get lower auto insurance rates in Newmarket.

Car insurance in Newmarket for seniors

If you’re a senior, chances are you have a long history of being insured. That’s a good thing! Auto insurance companies look fondly on years of experience, and clean driving records.

That said, those over 70 tend to see their rates creep up because they belong to a demographic that’s more likely to file a claim, statistically speaking. So if you start to see your rates increase, it’s time to shop around and compare rates to get the best price.

Car insurance in Newmarket for high-risk drivers

A high-risk driver is someone who’s received several traffic convictions, such as careless driving, distracted driving, or speeding. When that happens, insurance companies will deem you “high risk” and increase your rates to reflect the risk you pose to them.

There are some insurance companies who will insure high-risk drivers, but it’s possible that you can be turned away. If that happens, your last option is something called facility insurance, which is seen as an insurer of last resort — and facility premiums are much higher than traditional premiums.

Car insurance in Newmarket for new immigrants

If you recently immigrated to Ontario, you have 60 days to trade in the licence from the country you emigrated from and obtain an Ontario driver’s licence and insurance.

Next, you need to start the search for auto insurance. Ask your old insurance company to provide a reference to your new Ontario insurer. This could help lower your car insurance rate because you’ve got proof of past insurance and driving history.

Factors that impact car insurance rates in Newmarket

  • Traffic violations: In Newmarket, there are a number of things to keep an eye out for when it comes to abiding by the rules of the road. Firstly, this town uses radar speed boards to monitor speeding. According to data pulled from town radar speed signs, some streets, like Harry Walker Parkway, Main Street North, and Eagle Street, are much busier than others. As traffic violations can lead to increases in your car insurance rates, you’ll want to pay special attention to staying under 50 km/h in these areas.
  • Congestion: As Newmarket neighbours the city of Toronto, the city’s main highways are heavily trafficked. It’s important to keep this in mind when navigating Newmarket roads, as traffic often leads to collisions - which often lead to higher car insurance rates.

How to keep your car insurance rate low in Newmarket

  • Be a safe driver: Maintaining a clean driving history is one of the most surefire ways to ensure you’re getting a competitive car insurance rate. Luckily, Newmarket residents have a Safety Cone Sam to remind them to drive safely. Safety Cone Sam teaches us about good driving. Newmarket drivers have a colourful character that helps them stay safe on the road. Sam the Safety Cone is the official mascot of Safety Driven, Newmarket's public education campaign aimed at reinforcing good driving and discouraging speeding, aggressive driving, and other dangerous driving habits.
  • Use public transit: Another major factor in how much you’ll pay in car insurance is how much you drive. By using Newmarket’s many public transit options, you can reduce your mileage and effectively reduce your car insurance premiums as well. For instance, many Newmarket residents trek to and from Toronto every day, and they have several commuting options to choose from, such as GO Transit.
Lisa Coxon

Lisa Coxon

About the Author

Lisa is an Editor and Writer for Her work has appeared in Reader’s Digest, Toronto Life, Canadian Living and TVO. As a child, she diligently hoarded the $50 bills that fell out of her Christmas cards. Adult Lisa is working hard to resurrect those stockpiling tendencies.

Read More

Auto insurance news

Read More Like This