Compare car insurance quotes in St. Catharines for free. Find your best price in minutes.

Compare St. Catharines car insurance rates and save more than 27%.* 

Get quotes from 50+ Canadian providers in 3 minutes.

Get quotes from 50+ Canadian providers in 3 minutes.

Compare quotes from Canada's leading auto insurance providers

32,754 Canadians

have compared rates and saved money over the last 24 hours

What our users say:

April 22
Your agent Nathan was amazing and so…
Your agent Nathan was amazing and so helpful.
Alecia O'Brien
April 19
Prompt response
Prompt response. Good info to make a decision. Helpfull that info was sent to ...
Margaret Bird
April 19
Sean was easy to talk too and very…
Sean was easy to talk too and very informative.
Angela
April 19
Good job
The staff was helpful and knew what were doing.
Franziska Pedersen
April 17
Good pricing
Pleasant broker and helpful
Phyllis
April 17
filled out form online less than 5mins…
filled out form online less than 5mins called right away and setup call with bro...
ct
April 16
The Agent was very kind and helpful!
The Agent was very kind and helpful!
Istvan Kiraly
April 16
Great customer care she is good 👍
Great customer care she is good 👍
Anthony Odia
April 15
Simple and clear!!
Fast response ! Friendly knowledgeable staff!
Kent Fewer
April 15
great rep provided all the information…
great rep provided all the information I needed to make an informed choice
KAREN FOBERT
April 12
After I got the quotes somebody…
After I got the quotes somebody followed up with me and put me trough with an ag...
Stefan Ciucas
April 12
fast responce
fast responce, great people to talk to explaining everything, What a Great web s...
Larry Rowthorn
April 9
Very helpful advice and great overall…
Very helpful advice and great overall service.
mark
April 6
Easy to deal with and very helpful
Very easy, good use of technology and customer follow up was awesome
Steve Miller
April 6
Easy and friendly process.
Easy and friendly process.
shr
April 5
So good service ,,
So good service ,,, Tammy service me so so good
Son Nguyen
April 5
Very good service.
Very good service.
Tanya Neufeld Eckert
March 30
easy to work with…
easy to work with and find what I needed fast.
Pierre Duprey
March 25
Immediate response
Immediate response
Donald Henderson
March 6
Very helpful team !
Very helpful team !
Shivali Patel
February 15
Super fast seriously half the price!
Super fast seriously half the price of my previous broker. I worked with Khadija...
N. Gul
January 31
Representative was extremely helpful…
Representative was extremely helpful and was able to assist in all our needs.
Laura Dunsford
January 19
I was treated very well
I was treated very well, the person that was helping me was very helpful and fou...
Tim Bob
January 18
Great service
The response to my inquiry was quick. I received a phone call a few hours later ...
Sherri Leclerc
December 4
Quick turnaround
Quick turnaround, I am really happy with the process so far.
Breno Mendonca
November 11
process was easy and professional
The process was easy and professional
James Robichaud
November 1
The young man was very courteous and…
The young man was very courteous and professional. We didn't qualify due to low...
Teresa Penning
October 26
Quick and friendly response.
Quick and friendly response.
Dan Rochon Rochon

How comparing auto insurance quotes works. Hint: it’s free!

Compare

Next, we’ll show you quotes from 50+ Canadian providers. It’s free, with no commitment.

Save

When you find the best quote, secure your St. Catharines auto insurance rate by talking to a licensed broker or agent.

We can help you find cheap car insurance in St. Catharines.

It can be expensive to own and drive a car in St. Catharines. The good news? You’re not stuck with your current car insurance premium.

We’ve saved drivers in St. Catharines hundreds of dollars a year by shopping the car insurance market for them. In just three minutes, we compare rates from car insurance companies in St. Catharines. All it takes is some basic information about you and the vehicle you're looking to insure.

Enter your postal code now to get an estimate for car insurance in St. Catharines. Next, we'll connect you with a car insurance broker serving St Catharines who can help you lock in your new policy and take advantage of great rates.

Or, keep reading to learn more about how car insurance works in St. Catharines.

Front view of a car. Illustration.

See how our customers in St Catharines save big on auto insurance.

CustomerLocationVehicleLowest rateAverage rateSaved
Quote from April 24, 2024
Customer
Male, 48 years old
Location
st catharines
Vehicle
2019 HYUNDAI SANTA FE XL LUXURY V6 4DR AWD
Lowest Rate
$93/mth
$1,120/yr
Average Rate
$155/mth
$1,855/yr
Saved
$61/mth
39.62%
Quote from April 24, 2024
Customer
Male, 24 years old
Location
st catharines
Vehicle
2018 HONDA ACCORD SPORT 4DR
Lowest Rate
$449/mth
$5,382/yr
Average Rate
$542/mth
$6,505/yr
Saved
$94/mth
17.26%
Quote from April 24, 2024
Customer
Female, 29 years old
Location
st catharines
Vehicle
2016 DODGE/RAM GRAND CARAVAN SXT
Lowest Rate
$173/mth
$2,074/yr
Average Rate
$224/mth
$2,692/yr
Saved
$52/mth
22.96%

Auto insurance quotes are compared from CAA, Coachman Insurance Company, Economical Insurance, Gore Mutual, Onlia Insurance, Pafco, Pembridge, SGI, Travelers, Zenith Insurance Company

Focus on

Driving in St. Catharines.

Most popular cars in St. Catharines

The popularity of cars in St. Catharines is different from other cities in Ontario. According to data from LowestRates.ca, these are the most popular vehicles in the city.

Popular Brands

  1. Honda
  2. Hyundai
  3. Chevrolet
  4. Toyota
  5. Ford

Who shops for auto insurance quotes in St. Catharines?

With so many cars and so many drivers,  the roads in St. Catharines see quite a bit of traffic. Based on our data, here's who's looking for car insurance estimates in St. Catharines.

Gender of our users

Male
66%
Female
34%

Average Age

33

years old

Tickets & Accidents

Have Tickets
13.6%
Have Had Accidents
11.4%

What can I do to get cheap car insurance in St. Catharines?

It's easy — if you know how. Here are some of the best ways to lower your auto insurance premiums:

Shop around

We'll show you the most competitive rates from all the top insurers. Now you can compare quotes all in one place.

Buy the right coverage

Avoiding extra frills in your policy and paying for only the coverage you need will lower your premiums.

Drive responsibly

Your driving record impacts your rate. Fewer infractions and fines equals cheaper insurance.

Pay on time

Prompt payments can save you money on late fees and lower your premiums. Insurers love a good customer.

Bundle up

Adding a house, motorcycle, RV, or other type of insurance policy to your car insurance plan can lower your rates.

Be safe, not sorry

Safety features like winter tires and alarm systems can help reduce your insurance premium.

Stick with one insurer

Most auto insurance companies give special discounts to customers who stay with them for a number of years.

Take a course

A defensive driving course makes you a better driver and can significantly reduce your car insurance premiums.

Keep driving

The math is clear: more experience on the road equals lower car insurance premiums. Young drivers almost universally pay higher rates for car insurance. While it’s difficult for new drivers to secure cheap car insurance rates, you may be able to lower your rates by maintaining good grades and attending driving school.

Look at location

Where you drive affects your premiums. Some areas are associated with higher rates of car accidents and theft.

Choose the right car

Cars with high crash-test scores, low theft ratings, and less powerful engines tend to have cheaper insurance rates.

Track your driving

With a usage-based car insurance policy, you can turn your low-risk driving habits into lower premiums.

Your questions about car insurance in St. Catharines, answered.

 

How much is car insurance in St. Catharines?

The price of car insurance in St. Catharines will vary from driver to driver. On average, car insurance premiums in St. Catharines are about 50% per year higher than the Ontario average.

That said, almost no one pays the city average. The rate you're offered depends a lot on your individual circumstance. Everyone's insurance and driving histories are unique, plus there are other factors that insurers use to calculate your rate, including your gender, age, and postal code. Your specific rate may be higher or lower than the average rate.

Which St. Catharines postal code has the highest average car insurance premiums?

One of the biggest factors that will affect whether you can get affordable car insurance in St. Catharines is where you live. Those who live in postal code L2T have the highest average car insurance premiums. The L2T area is bordered to the north by the rail tracks, to the west by Twelve Mile Creek, to the south along St. David Road, and to the east by the Welland Canal.

Which St. Catharines postal code has the lowest average car insurance premiums?

Your address majorly influences what you’ll pay for automobile insurance in St. Catharines. On average, those who live in postal code L2N pay the cheapest for auto insurance in St. Catharines. This area is bordered by Lake Ontario to the north, Martindale Road in the west, the Queen Elizabeth Way highway to the south, and Vine St. to the east.

How do St. Catherines car insurance rates compare to other cities in Ontario?

Car insurance rates for neighbouring cities are comparable to St. Catharines'.

Drivers in St. Catharines pay on average 13% less for insurance than those in Niagara Falls see. It’s also 8% less than Niagara-on-the-Lake drivers’ annual premiums. That said, drivers in St. Catharines pay 5% more than drivers in nearby Welland and 10% more than those in Port Colborne.

Where do I get the cheapest car insurance quotes in St. Catharines?

To get the cheapest car insurance quotes in St. Catharines, you’ll want to compare rates from various companies. That’s because no auto insurance company in St. Catharines provides discounted rates to all customers who apply for coverage.

Car insurance policies are a custom product based on a number of factors — some of which are within your control (your driving history, your licence level) and some of which are out of your control (your age).

One way to ensure you’re getting the cheapest car insurance quotes is to use an online car insurance calculator for St. Catharines. An online rate comparison site such as LowestRates.ca makes it easy to compare rates from 50+ insurance providers in just a couple of minutes.

What factors affect the cost of car insurance in St. Catharines?

There are several different factors that affect the cost of car insurance in St. Catharines. Some of these factors are within your control, while others are not. Some factors that are within your control when it comes to car insurance in St. Catharines include:

  • Vehicle type. The type of vehicle you drive has a lot to do with your insurance premiums. A basic, utilitarian type vehicle will have lower premiums than a luxury, exotic, or another type of special vehicle.
  • Driving history. Your driving history is one of the most important factors when it comes to determining your auto insurance rates, and it is mostly within your control. Practice defensive driving, always follow the speed limit and rules of the road, and avoid aggressive driving to ensure your record remains spotless.
  • Vehicle use. People with a long daily commute will face higher insurance premiums than those who only use their vehicle for the occasional errand or trip.
  • Discounts. You may be eligible for discounts on your insurance — including student, driver’s education, or bundling. Ask your provider whether you qualify for any special savings program, and take advantage where you can.
  • Coverage. Finally, the amount of coverage you choose for your vehicle will affect your premium levels. This includes the amount of your deductible, with a higher deductible resulting in lower premiums than a lower deductible.

Factors that are outside of your control that will affect your insurance premiums include:

  • Age. Like it or not, young drivers pay higher insurance premiums than those in middle age. This is because they do not have the driving experience of their older counterparts, as well as lack an insurance history. Rates do begin to rise again for those 70+, as older drivers tend to have more accidents as they age. Car insurance for seniors in St. Catharines could be costly, as a result.
  • Gender. Whether you agree with it or not, men pay higher insurance premiums than women. This is because they tend to engage in riskier behaviours than their female counterparts, including speeding, drinking and driving, and driving without a seatbelt.
  • Postal code. Finally, your postal code has a big impact on your insurance rates. If your neighbours are making claims and having accidents, your insurance provider will deem you a higher risk as a result, and your premiums will be higher than someone who lives in an area with fewer claims.

When comparing rates, focus on the factors you can control rather than what you can’t in order to find the cheapest car insurance rates in St. Catharines. Don’t forget to compare car insurance quotes in advance of your policy renewal date. Insurance companies have different risk tolerance levels, meaning one may favour you more than your current insurance company and give you a lower rate. We can help you find a car insurance company serving St. Catharines that can offer you a lower rate.

What are car insurance rates in St. Catharines for students?

Car insurance for new drivers in St. Catharines, such as students, can be higher than insurance for more experienced drivers. This is because students often lack the driving history and experience of older drivers. If you’re looking for cheap car insurance in St. Catharines for new drivers such as students, ask about discounts for maintaining good grades, which many providers offer. They can also invest in a driver’s education program, which will help lower premiums.

What are car insurance rates in St. Catharines for new immigrants?

Like students, new immigrants are likely to face higher insurance premiums than most drivers in St. Catharines. This is because they lack a Canadian driving history and insurance history. One suggestion that may help new immigrants achieve lower insurance premiums is to ask your current insurance company for a letter that shows your history and driving record that you can present to your new, Canadian insurance provider.

What are car insurance rates in St. Catharines for high-risk drivers?

You’re likely to be put into the high-risk category with most insurance companies if you have several traffic convictions or have ever had your licence revoked. This high-risk designation means that insurance companies think that the likelihood of you needing to file a claim is high.

Because your chance of filing a claim is higher, insurance companies will charge you more. It can be challenging to find cheap auto insurance rates in St. Catharines as a high-risk driver, although there are a few insurance companies that cater specifically to high-risk drivers.

If you can’t secure standard insurance, you may be able to purchase facility insurance, which is a pool that is funded by Canadian insurance companies to offer coverage to high-risk drivers.

How can I reduce my car insurance premiums in St. Catharines?

The easiest way to reduce your car insurance premiums in St. Catharines is to focus on the factors that are within your control. Maintain a clean driving record, make your insurance payments on time, and choose the least amount of coverage that you require. Don’t forget to compare rates on a yearly basis ahead of your policy renewal to ensure that you’re getting the best rate possible. LowestRates.ca makes it easy to compare quotes from 50+ companies in just a matter of minutes.

Auto insurance news

Read More Like This

*Represents the average saved by shoppers who obtained a St. Catharines quote on LowestRates.ca and transacted via our contact centre between January and December 2022. The average savings amount represents the difference between the shoppers’ average lowest quoted premium and the average of the second and third lowest quoted premiums generated by LowestRates.ca.