Compare the best home insurance quotes in Barrie for free.

Save $300 or more on home insurance with LowestRates.ca.*

Get 50+ quotes in 3 minutes.

Compare quotes from Canada's leading home insurance providers

24,561 Canadians

have compared rates and saved money over the last 24 hours

What our users say:

October 8
Easy process, good quote found
Did an online quote and got a good rate. Went ahead and got in touch with the su...
Online Insurance Quote Seeker
October 6
Satiifed Customer
Very fast. Saved time. Efficient.
Doug Howes
October 5
Great CS
Great CS, clear attention. Good rates
Ivan Monroy
October 4
Miss Martin helped me out wonderfully
Miss Martin helped me out wonderfully! Thank you all!
Jonathan
October 3
Pleasure to talk to and deal with..
Pleasure to talk to and deal with... was straight forward with everything and wa...
Chris Flegg
October 3
Service professional was very nice and…
Service professional was very nice and helpful. Quick and easy process.
Beth Morrison
October 3
Christine B was awesome to deal with
Christine B was awesome to deal with. She explained everything I had questions a...
Michael Kirkham
October 3
The agent is very knowledgeable and…
The agent is very knowledgeable and experienced. He is also very respectful and ...
Varick Shand
October 1
They were very helpful in getting a…
They were very helpful in getting a insurance quote for my home and car. The quo...
Jim
October 1
VERY NICE CONVERSATION WITH MORE…
VERY NICE CONVERSATION WITH MORE EXPLANATION
Shemsedin Sheko
October 1
Quick and professional
Quick and professional
Abdul shakoor Abdul jalil
October 1
The guy was professional and prompt
The guy was professional and prompt, the entire call was only 5 mins to get ever...
Florin Palade
September 30
It gives the rate for various insurance…
It gives the rate for various insurance companies, and we can compare and decide...
Binoy Thomas
September 30
Very professional
Very professional
Rafiqul Islam
September 30
Tyler was a great help.
Tyler was a great help.
Carrie Beaudry
September 29
I really had a great experience talking…
I really had a great experience talking to Kate, she helped me tremendously and ...
Cynthia Rose
September 29
Answered all my questions and got me a…
Answered all my questions and got me a good quote
Ryan Catherwood
Taras Trofimov

Written by Taras Trofimov

Content Manager

Updated October 13, 2026

How comparing home insurance quotes works. Hint: it’s free!

Compare

Next, we’ll show you quotes from 50+ Canadian providers. It’s free, with no commitment.

Save

When you find the best quote, secure your Barrie home insurance rate by talking to a licensed broker or agent.

How much does Barrie home insurance cost in 2026?

Home insurance in Barrie costs around $1,630 – $1,990 per year as of 2026, according to LowestRates.ca’s latest quoter data. By contrast, Ontario home insurance premiums are around $1,875 – $2,170 per year, roughly $213 higher than Barrie’s (if you base the comparison on their midrange values).

How LowestRates.ca determines lowest and highest premiums

Estimated premiums are based on the average of the lowest two quoted premiums in 2026, with maximum available coverage for water protection using a profile of a 40-year-old homeowner, continuously insured for at least 10 years, who lives in a 2,500 sq ft detached house built 40 years ago, with brick veneer, wood frame construction, natural gas heat, a 10-year-old roof, and home replacement costs of $500,000.

Premiums are ordered according to Forward Sortation Areas (FSAs), which are the first three digits of a postal code, rounded to the nearest tenth. Premium ranges for each city are based on the lowest and highest premiums for each FSA. Ontario premium range is based on the median of all the lowest and highest premiums for each FSA.

About the comparison values

The comparison values are based on the midrange values for each city.

The formula to calculate the difference between each city is as follows:

((lowest premium + highest premium) ÷ 2) - ((lowest premium + highest premium) ÷ 2)

Example calculations:

  • Ontario midrange: ($1,875 + $2,170) ÷ 2 = $2,022.50
  • Toronto midrange: ($1,670 + $2,710) ÷ 2 = $2,190
  • Difference between Ontario and Toronto: $2,022.50 - $2,190 = -$167.50, rounded to -$168

Barrie vs. Ontario's major cities: Who gets the lowest home insurance premiums in 2026?

Out of the five major cities in Ontario, Ottawa has the highest premiums in 2026, at $1,510 – $3,080 per year. They are roughly $485 higher than Barrie's,  which are around $1,630 – $1,990 per year.

If you’re wondering where your specific Barrie neighbourhood falls in all of this, scroll on to find your postal code.

RankCityAnnual premium (lowest – highest)vs. Barrie

1

Barrie

$1,630 – $1,990

$0

2

St. Catharines

$1,590 – $2,040

~$5 higher

3

Hamilton

$1,450 – $2,290

~$60 higher

4

London

$1,740 – $2,410

~$265 higher

5

Toronto

$1,670 – $2,710

~$380 higher

6

Ottawa

$1,510 – $3,080

~$485 higher

Ontario annual premium (lowest – highest):
$1,875 – $2,170 (~$213 higher than Barrie)

Major cities were selected based on their population size, sourced from Canada Statistics, 2025 Population Estimates.

Barrie home insurance premiums by postal code

Postal codes with the highest home insurance premiums in Barrie start with L4M and L4N, paying around $1,860 – $1,990 per year.

Postal codeAnnual premium (lowest – highest)

L9J

$1,630 – $1,920

L4M

$1,860 – $1,990

L4N

$1,860 – $1,990

Barrie annual premium (lowest – highest): $1,630 – $1,990

The outlook on Barrie's home insurance premiums in 2026

Home insurance premiums in Ontario, and by extension, Barrie, are up in 2026 and are likely to continue to increase as we head into 2027.

Home premiums rose 5.8% year over year in Q2 2026 nationwide, according to the Applied Rate Index. Ontario saw an average premium increase of 4.2% year over year.

The silver lining for Ontario is that compared to Q1 2026, home insurance premiums are actually down — by 0.1%. The only other province to see a decrease from Q1 to Q2 in 2026 was Quebec, at 1.9%. The rest of the provinces saw an increase.

That said, year over year, the trend is unlikely to remain downward for Ontario.

QuarterAlbertaAtlantic
Provinces
OntarioQuebecB.C.Sask. & Man.

Q2 2026

11.9%

8.9%

4.2%

0.7%

1.9%

10.8%

Q1 2026

16.2%

10.8%

6.6%

4.0%

1.6%

11.2%

Q4 2025

13.5%

9.4%

4.3%

6.4%

1.7%

9.0%

Q3 2025

13.1%

7.3%

4.7%

11.2%

4.6%

8.9%

Q2 2025

9.5%

7.0%

5.0%

10.1%

1.0%

9.4%

Q1 2025

3.4%

4.2%

5.7%

9.6%

-5.9%

4.0%

Q4 2024

7.0%

4.5%

8.9%

8.5%

4.7%

7.9%

Q3 2024

5.5%

5.4%

10.4%

5.0%

7.6%

7.7%

Q2 2024

5.9%

7.9%

12.5%

4.7%

10.7%

8.3%

Q1 2024

10.4%

9.2%

12.7%

3.7%

18.3%

12.0%

Note: The percentages listed above are derived from comparing rates from one quarter to the same quarter in the prior year (e.g., Q2 2026 is compared to Q2 2025).

Source: The Applied Rate Index (Q2 2026)

What's driving Barrie home insurance premium increases in 2026?

A recent study by Statistics Canada shows that intensification in extreme weather events in the last six years, combined with an increase in rebuilding costs, have led to significant challenges for insurers across Canada. Here are some highlights:

Factor #1: Extreme weather intensification

Barrie has felt the effects of extreme weather firsthand. According to the City, the March 2025 ice storm damaged or destroyed approximately 12,000 street trees, and the March 2016 ice storm damaged or destroyed trees on 70% of the city’s streets. Heavy rains also overwhelmed Barrie’s drainage systems in June 2005 and June 2014, and the City reports more incidents of basement flooding in recent years.

As of now, there are no indications that this upward trend will reverse any time soon. Extreme weather is bound to only get worse in the future, with temperatures and precipitation continuing to increase at a rapid rate. Locally, the City’s Climate Change Adaptation Strategy projects that under a high-emissions scenario, historically rare extreme rain events will occur almost twice as often by mid-century, and days above 30°C will climb from 4 per year to 28 by the 2050s.

Factor #2: Surging rebuilding costs

As seen in the recent report by Verisk, residential rebuild costs in Ontario went up 23.8% from January 2021 to January 2026. As of 2026 Q1, YoY component costs are 3.8% higher across all of Canada, with Ontario sitting in the second place among the provinces at 4.4% YoY. The first spot belongs to British Columbia at 4.7% YoY.

Furthermore, due to a growing skilled trades shortage — as job vacancies are expected to climb at a rate of 13% between 2026 and 2045 — there’s a high chance that home rebuilding costs will remain elevated as well.

Factor #3: Profitability concerns

All these issues have resulted in profitability concerns and pushed insurers to increase their premiums. According to the study, homeowners’ home and mortgage insurance increased 45% from December 2019 to December 2025, outpacing even the all-items Consumer Price Index (inflation), which went up 21% over that time span.

The outlook is grim, yes, but that doesn't mean that consumers have no options. Comparison shopping is still the best way, by far, to secure a cheap premium. And like all things financial, price shopping should be a habit rather than a once-in-a-blue-moon activity.

Get the cheapest home insurance quotes by comparing the market

Your home might be the biggest purchase you’ll ever make. Protect it with a great home insurance policy. LowestRates.ca will bring you the cheapest house insurance quotes from all the top providers in your area.

Compare home insurance quotes from Canada's leading insurance providers in just 3 minutes.

Outline of a house. Illustration.

See how our customers in Barrie save big on home insurance.

Type of homeLocationPrevious claimsLowest rateAverage rateSaved
Quote from October 29, 2026
Type of home
Detached 1,546 sq ft
Location
Barrie
Previous claims
None
Lowest Rate
$113/mth
$1,350/yr
Average rate
$156/mth
$1,871/yr
Saved
$43/mth
$516/yr (28.00%)
Quote from October 29, 2026
Type of home
Detached 2,176 sq ft
Location
Barrie
Previous claims
None
Lowest Rate
$91/mth
$1,090/yr
Average rate
$165/mth
$1,980/yr
Saved
$74/mth
$888/yr (45.00%)
Quote from October 29, 2026
Type of home
Detached 1,438 sq ft
Location
Barrie
Previous claims
None
Lowest Rate
$140/mth
$1,675/yr
Average rate
$253/mth
$3,040/yr
Saved
$114/mth
$1,368/yr (45.00%)
Home insurance quotes are compared from CAA, Dominion Insurance, Economical Insurance, Gore Mutual, Max Insurance, Pembridge, SGI, and Wawanesa Insurance.
 

Tips on how to lower the cost of your home insurance policy in Barrie

Getting insurance for your home is easier than you think. To get the lowest rate possible, the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada recommends following these steps when shopping for home insurance.

Compare home insurance quotes from various providers.

Ask your broker or agent about bundling your home and car insurance policies.

Ask your broker or agent about which discounts you qualify for.

You might be able to further reduce your by increasing your deductible (the amount you pay toward a claim before your insurance kicks in) and by offering to pay your insurance bill annually instead of monthly.

Increasing your deductible is a great way to save on home insurance in the short term, just make sure you have money reserved for this purpose. Focusing on finding cheap quotes isn’t always a good idea. Having the right amount of coverage — now that should always be the goal.

Factors that determine your home insurance quote in Barrie

Your home insurance policy will be customized to suit your needs and the property you’re insuring.

Home insurance premiums are determined by dwelling type (is it a single-detached home, a house with a basement tenant suite, or a condo?). Insurance companies also try to predict the kind and size of claim you might make in the future.

Here are some of the criteria insurance companies look at when calculating your premium.

  • The square footage of your home.
  • Contents and quality of construction.
  • The location of your home.
  • Distance to a fire hydrant.
  • Your insurance claims history.
  • The age of your roof.
  • Your home’s plumbing.
  • Your home’s electrical system.

Your Barrie home insurance questions, answered

What kind of perils are specific to Barrie?

There are some specific risks to be aware of when it comes to house insurance in Barrie:

  • Ice or hail storms. This sort of event can damage exterior features of your home, and in extreme cases cause roof damage and subsequent flooding. These weather events happen relatively frequently in Barrie; so, while it is likely to be covered, it will likely affect your premiums.
  • Wind damage. A quiet street with a nice tree canopy can be a wonderful place to live. However, severe windstorms can cause branches to break and land on properties in your neighbourhood, which can also impact your premiums.
  • Heavy snowfall. Residential roofs are only designed to carry so much weight. In the event of a severe blizzard, roofs can experience moisture damage, or even collapse under the weight of heavy snow. Southern Ontario (and Barrie, specifically) tends to get a lot of snowfall in winter, so this also could impact your home insurance premiums in Barrie.

What risks does home insurance cover in Barrie?

Different regions have different environmental risks. Home insurance providers in Barrie tailor their offerings to the risk profile of the region they’re serving, and of course, any laws and regulations that are relevant.

Generally speaking, events that are unexpected are covered in most policies, while events an insurance company considers predictable are not covered. Here are some risks you can expect to see covered in many of the policies you might be offered.

  • Fires resulting from accidents or weather events (such as lightning strikes).
  • Damage from debris (such as tree branches) from high wind weather events.
  • Theft of property from a break-in.
  • Inside-the-home water damage (such as damaged pipes).
  • Damage occurring from ice or hail storms.

However, there are some events that are unlikely to happen in Barrie that most insurance companies will not cover.

What risks won’t home insurance cover in Barrie?

Remember, not all threats to homes are covered with a standard homeowner's insurance policy in Barrie. In addition to insured perils, there are also natural disasters that are unlikely to happen near where you live, and damage from these sorts of events is not likely to be covered by most home insurance providers. Some of these may include:

  • Earthquakes
  • Landslides
  • Overland flooding

There are also events that are more likely to occur which an insurance company generally will not cover. These generally are considered the homeowner’s responsibility, for example:

  • Conventional weathering of roof shingles, siding, and other exterior features.
  • Damage resulting from do-it-yourself home repairs
  • Damage from neglect.

What kind of home insurance do you need in Barrie?

Here are the main types of home insurance policies you need to consider for your Barrie dwelling:

Comprehensive - This type of home insurance covers the structure of your home and its contents from all risks, except risks that are generally considered uninsurable (damage from earthquakes and overland flooding, for example).

Basic or Named Perils - This is the opposite of a comprehensive policy. Only those risks that are explicitly included by name are covered by these sorts of plans. For example, if the policy does not mention fire damage, then a claim filed as a result of fire damage will not be accepted.

Broad - Also known as a “broad-form” policy, these plans tend to provide coverage that is a hybrid of comprehensive and basic insurance. For the home itself, these policies are similar to comprehensive plans, in that they cover all perils other than those are uninsurable. For the belongings in your home, broad policies tend to name the risks that are covered, while all unnamed risks are not covered.

No-Frills - As the name suggests, a no-frills policy offers limited coverage for properties that don’t meet the standards of insurance providers. Some homes under these policies have structural defects or other issues.

In addition to the risks covered in these policies, customers also have the option of purchasing endorsements. An endorsement is an agreement between an insurance company and customer to have an additional risk covered in an insurance policy, usually for an additional cost. Some endorsements homeowners in Barrie might consider:

  • Overland flooding occurs from the overflowing of rivers or lakes as a result of the melting of ice and snow, or heavy rainfall.
  • Flooding from heavy rain over your house.
  • Sewer backup. This can occur from weather events, construction accidents, or from poor municipal maintenance.

What can you do to save on home insurance in Barrie?

Finding cheap home insurance in Barrie doesn’t have to be difficult. The price of home insurance in Barrie depends on a number of factors, including the size and the quality of the area’s insurance pool, as well as external factors such as extreme weather risks.

In many cases, insurance companies will offer discounts to customers who bundle their policies or take steps to reduce risks. Some examples of these discounts might include:

  • Bundling: If an insurance company can administer the insurance of an automobile and home with the same account, they usually offer discounts.
  • Installing safety equipment: Installing home safety and monitoring equipment reduces the likelihood of your home being broken into.
  • Reducing risks: Keeping your home smoke-free and making repairs to decrease the risk of your basement flooding are examples of lower claim risks that often result in discounts.
  • Shop around. It’s important to compare house insurance quotes in Barrie from a variety of providers. Rate comparison tools are useful for quickly comparing the offerings of multiple competitors in just a few clicks in order to find the best home insurance rates in Barrie.

What are the best home insurance companies in Barrie?

Everyone’s experience with insurance providers will be unique because insurance policies are tailored to the individual needs and circumstances of each customer.

Once you make sure your provider is licensed to operate, it’s important to make sure your home insurance provider suits your home and your family’s needs. Rating agencies can offer useful insights through customer surveys, but ultimately, the best insurance provider for your next-door neighbour might not be the right one for you.

Experts recommend gathering as much information from as many reputable sources as you can. Once you’ve narrowed your search, take the time to communicate with a home insurance broker in Barrie before making a final decision.

There are many licensed home insurance providers serving Barrie. Don’t forget to shop around and compare Barrie's home insurance rates to make sure you’re getting current home insurance rates in Barrie.

What if I own a condo or rent? Can I still buy property insurance online?

LowestRates.ca can help you find property insurance in Barrie. To get started, enter your postal code above and select either the condo or renters' insurance option. We have more information on finding the best condo insurance or renters' insurance.

Taras Trofimov

Taras Trofimov

About the Author

Taras is the Content Manager for LowestRates.ca. He has produced thought leadership content for organizations like Constellation Software, Facebook and Yellow Pages as well as outlets like The Globe and Mail, Autoblog and MSN Autos.

Home insurance news

Read More Like This

*More than 50% of LowestRates.ca users in Ontario who obtained a home insurance quote from January to December 2025 saw savings ranging from $150 to $650, with an average savings of $352.84. The average savings amount represents the difference between the users’ average lowest quoted premium and the average of the second and third lowest quoted premiums generated by LowestRates.ca..